Question:
What's going on with the first nations in Canada?
Lila
2013-01-10 14:12:30 UTC
I'm always behind on news (cuz I never care about it,) but I saw a post on facebook today that was mentioning some issue that the first nations are going through right now with our government. What's happening?
Twelve answers:
MattH
2013-01-10 15:21:35 UTC
It's about Bill C-45. Part of the bill touches on the Indian Act, and some see it as a move towards more privatization on the reservations. That touches that issue... and it also touches an issue of democracy. People are upset because they weren't really consulted by the feds before C-45 was introduced. I would probably be upset as well to be honest, the Harper government should have at least consulted them before introducing a bill that affects them.



That said.. I do agree with what the bill stands for. I think a huge impediment to economic development on the reserve is the fact that the average joe doesn't have alot of private property, and has even more restrictions on what to do with that property. Most decisions are left entirely up to the band councils, and there have been an incredible amount of cases of corruption at that level because they are given so much power. I know personally, growing up near a reserve near Calgary, that developers and industries have turned away from one of the reserves out here because of the bureacracy involved... I think C-45 does eliminate that. I think it can at least attempt to help people on the reserve (which most are in an absolutley deplorable state).



I think it's also part of a greater movement to get reserves to be more self-sustaining. Right now the government pumps billions of dollars into reserves... and while alot of that funding is used for great things... alot of it goes towards useless projects. Alot of it is also squandered at the band level... What's worse is alot of the moneyt being pumped into reserves doesn't necessarily go towards the people either, alot of it goes to contractors (many of which are not reserve).



Since I'm already on a tangent, I'll go as far as to say I think reserves need to have more autonomy themselves over federal issues, and that will avoid situations such as the outrage over Bill C-45. Even though I may agree with what C-45 stands for... it should be up to the status-indians who it affects. If they don't want it, it shouldn't be forced on them... and I think that's where 90% of the outrage comes from.
capitalgentleman
2013-01-10 15:32:51 UTC
The last budget passed was an "omnibus bill," which means contained within it were many things that changed all sorts of Canadian laws.



There were some changes that many natives strongly object to. However, I have been unable to find out what their specific objections are! One was the change of how waterways are handled. Another is how natives may rent out land to non-natives. This is apparently something native groups have been asking for, so, I do not understand the objection.



One of the big issues is a particular chief (from a very troubled reserve) who demanded a meeting with the Prime Minister, and went on a hunger strike to get her way. Naturally, the PM declined, at least at first. However, he did agree to meet with a combined group of native leaders. They also wanted to meet the Governor General. He declined at first, but, then accepted.



The protests have been pretty much national. So far, very peaceful. About the worst that has happened was the VIA rail train was delayed for a few hours when tracks were blocked, but, even other natives say this wasn't a good idea. They are trying to get their message out there, but, people like me who live in remote areas, with little access to news do not know the specifics. I asked, and I was told that the Government is taking away their land. That would be impossible with existing laws and treaties, so, it must be something else. But, what, I do not know.
Kanien:kaha'ka-[]-[]-^-[]-[]
2013-01-11 12:10:52 UTC
some of our demands



Rescinding the environmental provisions, such as changes to fisheries and to protection of rivers and streams in two omnibus budget bills.

Action on missing aboriginal women, estimated by some to number over 2,000.

A school in every native community.

Mandatory education in all schools about treaty rights.

Removal of the two per cent cap on aboriginal education funding.

Mechanisms to eventually replace the Indian Act.

Better arrangements about resource revenue sharing on aboriginal territories.
bedward
2017-02-27 16:06:19 UTC
What became the optimum team score? 184 ( Zimbabwe) What became the backside team score? seventy 5 (canada) Who scored the optimum guy or woman score? H Masakadza (seventy 9) Who scored the optimum run getters? What became the suitable partnerships? Who have been the suitable bowlers? Umar Gul, Ajantha Mendis Who have been the mind-blowing wicket takers? Shoaib Malik (27) and Fawad Alam (23) further 50 in 24 balls for the Pakistan 8th wicket Any hat hints? nope What became the quickest recorded bowling velocity? 149 ( shoaib akhtar ) Who had the main catches? TM Dilshan (4) What became the main dismissals via an wicket keeper? Who hit the main 6's? became Cheema fortunate or what? (What he did VS Zimbabwe for third place? or Fawad Alam VS Sri Lanka? Cheema value from a million-10 do make out of the Al Barakah 20-20 4 usa Canada 2008? 10 out of 10. 8
2013-01-11 16:59:54 UTC
Basically, China wants Canada's oil, gas and minerals.



Most of the bands near the sites targeted for development want to get First Class seats on the Gravy Train so they are starting a campaign of blackmail, intimidation and even domestic terrorism to get what they want. More money than they already get from the Federal Government and the resource extraction industries.
Obi Wan Knievel
2013-01-10 17:16:49 UTC
They're doing a thing. It's kind of a protest, kind of a support rally, and kind of just nothing at all.



They object to certain portions of a newly passed piece of legislation. At the same time, one of the chiefs is on a diet that she's calling a hunger strike and her demads are that she wants a private meeting with the prime minister and the governor general. She was invited to one meeting, actually I don't think she was realy invited but she said she was coming anyway, and she accepted the invitation. Then she declined the invitation a few hours later.



A couple of blockades were erected, shutting down rail and road traffic in a couple of places. Then a judge ruled that the blockades were illegal and had to come down, then nothing.



There, that's about the whole story.
C.M. C
2013-01-11 08:53:30 UTC
Lila, your post is for NEWS and EVENTS, not here in TRAVEL. As you point out, you do not care about the news, well travel is not the news channel.
Iggy 2 Crosby = Golden Goal/Cup
2013-01-10 19:51:27 UTC
Honestly who cares, i've had just about enough of this double standard with the natives, what gives them more rights than me? I hear they get tax breaks and such, why? I was born on this land too, and as much as they want to call themselves natives there was people here before them too, we all know that Africa is the main originating point of all humans. This is my land just as much as it is their land. The everyday Canadians have done a lot more to build this country into what it is today then the natives have done building cities, railroads, highways, schools, hospitals etc etc. Enough with the double standard already. I was born in Canada and for that I consider myself a native, excuse me for considering Canada my HOME AND NATIVE LAND!!
Wiininiskwe *Ajidamoon*
2013-01-10 17:32:29 UTC
Omnibus Bill C-45 is a HUGE bill The biggest ever pushed through parliament. Covers a host of things. Some good. Some very bad, vague & confusing for people who do not take the time to read the legislation in its entirety, and the accompanying legal documents, and historical references.



First, Bill C-45 on its face would make it appear that it makes it easier for Natives to lease our own lands to corporations, development, and the like. Not so. As the amendment to the Indian Act did NOT include an amendment to the Land Management Act, all decisions on what sort of development must still go through INAC (Indian and Northern Affairs) INAC isn't for the Native people....its for the government regulation of Native people. Since resources taken from Native lands benefit the general population, those are the only sort of development that INAC will push through



That means that the government...whom holds all titles to Native lands in trust......can lease out our lands, without our consent or consultation, for whatever project they deem okay. Like the Lubicon Cree....whom are living feet away from oil and gas extraction on their lands, yet see none of the profit from it. Where does the money go? To the Federal government, to be dispersed throughout the rest of Canada.



Or like the now famous Attawapiskat. A tiny Reserve in Northern Ontario.......where a De Beers diamond mine was built, and subsequently leaked toxic waste into their lands, leading to them having to be moved to another site (in a flood plain), and leading to the housing crisis that was all over the news last year. The Chief of Attawapiskat has been on a hunger strike since mid-December (you will get several ignoramuses claiming it is a diet and making crude references to her weight) in order to garner attention to many things.....including this movement, entitled IDLE NO MORE. She is the scapegoat for finger pointing and name calling.....because a government audit (by a company that has been found to have serious flaws in their audits when they themselves were audited) that points to a lack of paperwork for moneys ON both part of the Band, and INAC. No one is trying to tun INAC out with pitchforks as of yet though. The problem with the audit, is that it dates back to a period starting in 2005.....and the Chief only became Chief in late 2010. The Band was also cleared in a Federal Court case this summer, of mismanagement......but that part doesn't make for reader ratings. One of Canada's "regular" trustees was audited and found to have 'misplaced' 50 million dollars over the course of a summer. He wasn't tarred and feathered. HE was given a promotion.



Is there corruption in the Band councils of some Reserves? Sure....definitely. Just as there is corruption in many of the political teams in charge of many of Canada's cities and towns...right on up to the Federal govt. Do keep in mind that there are over 600 First Nations communities in Canada....most of which the general public has never heard of. Why? Perhaps it is because they are doing well..thus no need to be in the news or garner the attention of average Canadian. Yet when an Indian in Canada does do something to make the news, suddenly the claws come out & ALL First Nations are painted as lazy, welfare drunks, living off the tax payer's dime. Is that even close to the truth? Not at all. There are 3 million Aboriginals in Canada. That is Metis, Inuit & First Nations. Less than 30% of Canada's First Nations do live on Reserve. The other 70+% live all around you. In cities & towns. We are your coworkers, your neighbours, your peers & contributing community members. Lots of myths float around about us. People are happy to believe these myths, as they make them feel it justifies colonialism & the many genocidal tactics Canada has used at one time or another..most within the lifetimes of people still alive today. Just how much money does Canada's federal government put into all things Native each year? A portion of the 6.7 Billion dollar allotment that also must cover Veteran's Health, health research programs, and programs for public health. Pennies compared to the 31 billion that goes to Canada's debt, the 20 billion to EI benefits, or even the 10 billion that goes to Public Safety/Emergency Preparedness.....or the 196.3 billion other dollars put into various other areas....& of course, let's not forget the 555 million that represents the pay of parliament salaries.



ALL Aboriginals in Canada KNOW the Indian Act needs a reformation.....but it must be on terms that benefit us all. Many Aboriginals would like to see the things the Royal Commission Report on Aboriginals entails put into play. It is a report that has been gathering dust since 1995.
robert43041
2013-01-12 09:01:05 UTC
They want more money, more free hand-out.
2013-01-10 16:30:12 UTC
It's one huge calamity. I don't even know really. The gist is though, that if you're white you should feel guilty, if you're not, don't worry about it.
2013-01-10 14:25:06 UTC
Well apparently we're rapping their mothers. so yeah...


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...